Lawyers’ boycott, Xhafaj: The HJI can intervene! Chief Inspector Metani: It does not depend only on us
The Commission for Civic Initiatives, Cooperation and Institutional Oversight this Tuesday dealt with and discussed the lawyers’ boycott.
The Commission’s chairman, Fatmir Xhafaj, during the discussion with the High Justice Inspector, Artur Metani, said that this is an open public disagreement between the lawyers and the Special Court (GJKKO). He added that the consequences are direct for the system, the delivery of justice and citizens directly.
Xhafaj, among other things, asked Metani whether the High Justice Inspectorate (HJI) can intervene to find a lawful solution and overcome the deadlock. Metani, for his part, stressed that the institution he leads follows it with great attention, but acts within the limits of its legal competences.
Discussions: Xhafaj: Today we have a deadlock created at the Special Court of First Instance. There is an open public disagreement between the lawyers and the Special Court. Is there a possibility, an effort, an intervention by the Inspector to resolve it, because in the end what suffers is the system, the delivery of justice and citizens directly. We have this concern. Do you see yourselves, within the competences the law gives you, as able to intervene to find a lawful, fair solution, so that this deadlock is overcome?
Metani: We follow it with great attention and every day we have discussions about what is happening. To be strictly legal, with the competences of the HJI, as we have seen it from this viewpoint, first it would degenerate or go towards a violation of a disciplinary nature. Secondly, what you said is more part of a table between the parties that have this discussion and this goes beyond the competences that the HJI has, and also has more to do with human characters than with the legal discussions that can be held between the parties. I do not have an opinion today, but we follow it with great attention as far as concerns us. As an institution we would be ready to help as much as we could help, but it is not something that depends only on the desire of the HJI Inspector.
Xhafaj: I think a little differently. There is a position from where the Inspector can intervene, because there a very important principle is violated, which is due process of law. There is also a direct consequence, which is the prolongation of court processes and, from this viewpoint, the Inspector can intervene. I do not question the act. We are all together concerned by the deadlock created, the effect it brings. As for what the solution is, it belongs to the parties, because they are not individuals, but institutions. An intervention would be reasonable. I hold to that on which the system itself is built. We talk about balances and reciprocal control and, in this aspect, the HJI has an important role to preserve this balance. We are involved in three important issues: criminal cases, due process of law and the third is related to backlogged cases, in the sense of normal exceeding.
Metani: This is also my personal viewpoint, that the relationship this Commission should have with the HJI, first, is to share here the concerns that we have, then the Commission should also exercise its role for oversight of the activity of the justice institutions. Secondly, as you said, I would see the relationship between the Commission and the Justice Inspector very much as a partnership. The Commission can even ask the High Justice Inspector to carry out certain thematic inspections because of its own activity. The HJI will respond, as much as we can, with our help and our inspections, precisely to go to that common aim: for the Commission to come out with a mature opinion on the concerns the justice system has, the problems and the way these concerns should be fixed. Meanwhile, in conclusion, yes, undoubtedly we are ready to help the Commission and to be partners in this process, as much as we can help you.



Komentet
Bëhu i pari që komenton!
Lini një Koment të Ri
Për t'u përgjigjur një komenti specifik, kliko butonin 💬 Përgjigju poshtë atij komenti.