Commission for Citizen Initiatives, Cooperation and Institutional Oversight holds hearings with the HJI, HJC and HPC
Under the chairmanship of Fatmir Xhafaj, the Commission for Citizen Initiatives, Cooperation and Institutional Oversight held several hearings, in implementation of the Thematic Calendar for the Exercise of Post-Legislative Parliamentary Control, within Component III, which relates to the adoption of by-laws and the level of implementation of the laws adopted during the 2021–2025 period, Component III “Independent Institutions and Agencies”.
First, the Commission held a hearing with Artur Metani, the High Justice Inspector, who reported on the fulfilment of the obligations to draft and adopt by-laws, and underlined that there had been no obligations to draft any by-law for the implementation of the Cross-Sector Justice Strategy, nor any obligation to be fulfilled within the integration process for alignment with the EU “acquis”.
Metani focused on meeting the progress report’s recommendations regarding filling the vacancies for inspectors at the HJI office, meeting the recommendations to increase thematic inspections, and drafting a special methodology to meet the recommendation for the further implementation of vetting standards in the activity of the HJI bodies.
Rapporteur Romina Kuko stated that parliamentary control should not be limited to the formal fulfilment of legal obligations, but should assess whether the HJI’s activity produces concrete results in verifying complaints and the inspections carried out, and she focused on several issues related to: the handling of complaints linked to delays in court proceedings, inspections in courts with problematic case backlogs, the need to increase transparency; the deadlines and effectiveness of inspections, the procedures for recruiting inspectors, the need to draft periodic reports on citizens’ complaints, etc.
Kuko proposed, among other things, that the HJI improve the registration and verification of complaints about delays, publish periodic reports and the criteria for selecting inspections, and include in the 2027 inspection plan the duration of trials in priority courts as defined by the Strategy, the administrative courts and corruption in the judiciary; etc. She also asked the HJI to present to the Commission, within 30 days, a calendar for filling the vacant posts and evaluating inspectors by the end of 2027, and to send the Commission the 2027 inspection plan as soon as it is approved. Metani then answered the MPs’ questions.
The second session continued with Ilir Rusi, President of the High Judicial Council, who summarised the process of drafting by-laws during the 2021-2025 period, detailing that in the three main justice reform laws, 85 provisions have been identified that foresee obligations for the issuance of acts by the HJC, of which 59 have been fulfilled, while 26 others remain to be approved. Rusi explained that most of the acts relate to judges’ career development, ethical-professional evaluation, disciplinary proceedings, financial compensation, court administration, the efficiency of the judiciary, and communication with the media and the public. Among other things, Rusi explained that some of the areas where new acts are still needed include the continuing training of magistrates, environmental incompatibility, disability compensation, workload reduction, etc. MP Romina Kuko, in her capacity as rapporteur, noted that the HJC must fulfil legal obligations carried over for years, as well as several problems encountered in court administration, delays in trials, the lack of approval of rules for evaluating the work of HJC members, the lack of a unified procedure for transfers, etc.
Kuko proposed that the HJC present to the Commission, within 30 days, a detailed overview of the 26 provisions not covered by by-laws, specifying the drafting stage, the responsible structure and the approval deadline for each. Among other things, Kuko asked for the approval of rules for the evaluation and ranking of candidates, as well as reasoned proposals for legal changes in cases where the HJC considers the acts unnecessary. Rusi then answered the MPs’ questions.
The meeting continued with the hearing with Mirela Bogdani, President of the High Prosecutorial Council, and Vatё Staka and Erind Mёrkuri, members of the HPC. Bogdani first reported on the process of drafting by-laws during the 2021-2025 period, detailing that 25 regulations and strategies have been approved, which relate mainly to evaluation, parallel movement, prosecutors’ careers, communication with the public, and several issues related to the merging of disciplinary proceedings, the internal functioning of the HPC, etc. Bogdani then also focused on the reasons for the failure to approve a number of acts on time and the stages at which their approval stands. MP Erjo Mile, in his capacity as rapporteur, noted the delays in fulfilling the obligations to approve by-laws, the failure to implement the Assembly’s recommendations on time, the slow pace of prosecutors’ professional evaluation, etc.
The rapporteur proposed that the HPC present a full inventory of the 17 unapproved acts, with the drafting stage, the responsible structure and the approval date for each; present a plan for completing the carried-over evaluations of prosecutors, etc. The HPC representatives then answered various questions from the MPs.
There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment.



Komentet
Bëhu i pari që komenton!
Lini një Koment të Ri
Për t'u përgjigjur një komenti specifik, kliko butonin 💬 Përgjigju poshtë atij komenti.